The Read

At some point, Black America must say enough is enough when it comes to tolerating academic failure. The time must be now.
All the news inside — and outside — the dropout nation. Updated throughout the day (new items and updates are marked with an *):
- Bad instruction + Bad parenting = poor academic performance: How poorly did San Francisco’s black students in the 2nd, 3rd and 4th grade perform on the latest round of state tests? Reports the San Francisco Chronicle: “Special education students had slightly higher proficiency rates than black students in second-, third- and fourth-grade math as well as fourth-grade English.” No wonder why black middle class residents who can afford to move to Silicon Valley or to cities with better-performing school systems, do so. Educational genocide at work, dear folks. And this must stop.
- Meet one of L.A. Unified’s worst dropout factories: Just north of Compton and near the famed Hancock Park, Jefferson High School has been blessed with a beautiful Art Deco building and an alumni list that includes diplomat extraordinaire Ralph Bunch, dance impresario Alvin Ailey and saxophonist Dexter Gordon. But the school has become more notorious for schoolyard brawls, being at the center of the battle between the district and charter school outfit Green Dot schools (which opened five charter schools surrounding Jefferson in response to parent complaints about the school) and pervasive academic failure. And during the 2006-07 school year, it has garnered the status of being one of the state’s worst dropout factories, according to the Associated Press. Six out of every ten freshmen leave school without a sheepskin, making it the worst-performing dropout factory among the academic roach motels run by L.A. Unified.
- Public school choice? What public school choice*: Parents and students in Washington, D.C.’s woeful public schools just got notices that they qualify for the public school choice option under No Child, by which they can transfer from one failing school to a better one. But as the Washington Post reports, the parents already know that the choices they face in the school system are grim to none. And the notifications come out so late that the options aren’t available at all. As I’ve mentioned last week, public school choice doesn’t exist for most parents and students in any form.
- Building for nothing: Back in 2001, Milwaukee Public Schools embarked on a $102 million building spree in order to create local schools and in order to eschew the more destructive elements of school busing. This despite the fact that the district, like so many urban systems, has seen three decades of declining enrollment. The results, as reported by the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel in a three-part series, is, well, predictable: Students are still being bused to schools outside their respective neighborhoods; new additions and old buildings are sitting half-empty or — for the shame of the district — being rented out to private schools. And combo efforts such as building a church alongside another public school has gone awry, with both students and parishioners taking the hit.
- The Milwaukee schools experience offers another reason for a new model: Over the past three years, I’ve floated something I call the Hollywood model for public education under which local school districts would move from becoming operators of schools and masters of academic instruction — a job which many people argue (and the evidence suggests), they don’t do so well — to becoming a dormitory authority similar to the state agency used in New York state to build colleges. Similar to the major motion picture studios (which rarely produce films, but focus on distribution and finance), school district would construct buildings, provide school lunch services and handle transportation services on behalf of public charter schools and private schools(none of which have the scale to do those jobs efficiently). The charter schools and private schools would become, essentially, become like small-shingle Hollywood studios, handling the instructional work that districts used to do. This embraces public education as being a system of financing the best options for every student, no matter their race or income, while maximizing the public dollars that are in place. The reality is that public school districts are actually pretty good in constructing buildings and moving people around, not so good at academic instruction or data systems. A Hollywood model of education may not be such a bad idea after all.
- Speaking of building: Public school officials in New Orleans plans on building 28 new school buildings while selling off or otherwise jettisoning 50 others as part of a $685 million plan funded by FEMA funds, according to the Times-Picayune. The key part of the plan: A separate authority that would essentially build and manage the buildings on behalf of both the existing traditional public school system, the Recovery District of charters and traditional public schools run by the state and other entities. Essentially, this could be the Hollywood model at work — if the penchant of officials for corruption and sleaze doesn’t trump the goal of efficient building.
- Better middle schools, New York style: The Daily News offers some suggestions on middle schools that aren’t “middle of the pack.” Check it out.
- A challenge*: Jay Greene asks the Broader, Bolder crowd to put their words to practice by coming up with a test model of their proposed community school concept. Save for Leo Casey’s response and a small missive from Lawrence Mishel, no response has been forthcoming from the group in response to other criticisms of their anti-accountability plan.
- From my end*, Broader, Bolder is right to note that a better approach to the current public welfare system — one that offers some form of wrap-around help for families in need — is probably needed for the children coming out of poverty-minded homes. But schools cannot abdicate their responsibility for educating these children and preparing them for higher education and life. Good teachers can overcome other socioeconomic problems. But good instruction and rigorous curricula must first be provided by schools in order for this to happen.
- And feel free* to check out my latest piece for The American Spectator, this time, on how Reason magazine’s rating of Chicago as the most nanny-statelike city in America doesn’t fully consider all the problems of the City of Broad Shoulders. For most people, the Second City’s status as first in the nation when it comes to corruption — along with its underperforming schools — is far more disconcerting than its anti-liberty coddling and toddling.











I was very interested to read your insightful comments, and I think you might be interested in a book written on similar lines by a colleague and myself, published in October, 2008. FYI here is the press release and website.
Kind regards,
Linda Carlson, Ph.D.
Contact: Linda Carlson Marilyn Felix
Email: interwovenideas@hotmail.com
EDUCATION: The Emperor’s New Clothes
Why Students fail in School and a New Approach to Undo the Decay
The urgent need to get the word out about educational inadequacies compelled teachers and authors, Dr. Linda Carlson and Marilyn Felix to write—Education: The Emperor’s New Clothes, in order to draw attention to the many root causes of these problems. Simple strategies are presented which if implemented, could turn the system around for the better.
Intense discussions about governmental meddling, shocking educational failure statistics and teacher frustration are plainly stated with no pandering to political correctness. The No Child Left Behind Act, while an ideal vision is in reality an illusion—especially for approximately thirty percent of students in American high schools who fail. This book boldly addresses many of the conspicuous errors of judgment and practices in schools today, and gives novel solutions.
“…this is an extraordinarily well-written book about a difficult subject. Before reading it, I had the simplistic view that the deficiencies of the educational system in the USA were due to the teachers, the teachers unions and to a large extent, the problem of tenure. I now realize that this is a much more complex subject…a very thought-provoking book.”—Michael Barnes, M.D., author.
“As I read each page, I felt like I was scampering through a backyard of synaptic clotheslines strung with 35 years of diverse and pleasant teaching memories.”—Lee Dupree, retired teacher.
Education: The Emperor’s New Clothes is an easy read, peppered with hair-curling comments and irony.
Publisher’s website: http://www.strategicbookpublishing.com/Education.html
About the Authors:
Dr. Linda Carlson and Marilyn Felix wrote this book to give a voice to the enormous numbers of frustrated teachers, parents and students struggling with an education system that has failed them. The inspirations for this book were the ever-increasing student dropout statistics, and the empathy felt for teachers burdened by insurmountable government mandates. The authors have over fifty years of combined teaching experience at all levels. They used world-wide surveys, personal communications and their broad experience in different teaching settings as the raw fabric for this book. The vast host of opinions voiced range from H.R.H Prince Charles to a Greenlandic teacher. Linda and Marilyn were both born in Britain; both married Americans and currently live in Cañon City, Colorado.
For media inquiries, appearances, or other publicity — please contact:
Ellen Green — PressManager@aegpublishinggroup.com
AEG Publishing Group, Inc.
845 Third Avenue, 6th floor-6016 – New York, NY 10022
http://www.Strategicbookpublishing.com – http://www.EloquentBooks.com – http://www.StrategicBookMarketing.com
1-888-808-6190 – Corporate Office